It happened. No matter how long ago, a person’s life was ruined. That person was seriously hurt, probably even physically, but definitely mentally…and those scars fucking stay. So, it shouldn’t matter how long ago it happened…just that it did happen.


That’s the fucked up thing! They caught a like 93 year old Nazi not that long ago, and I saw people who were asking what the point of putting him in jail was! And the Golden State Killer! People were genuinely suggesting that he should be let out because he’s old and hadn’t killed anyone in a while that we know of for a while. Fuck.
Some people view prison as a place for rehabilitation. If the person is likely to never get out because of age then what’s the point of rehabilitating?
I don’t personally subscribe to that for violent crimes, but I’d say that rehabilitation requires acceptance of consequences, and evading punishment puts them back into “sequester from the general population” territory.
I see it as both, rehabilitation and punishment. I don’t think there are many who only the rehabilitation…
I do, otherwise it’s just wanton punishment for the sake of punishment. I believe in harm reduction, not harm multiplication, so if there is no benefit to the people involved or society and we’re still choosing punishment I generally disagree with punishment simply for the sake of punishment.
so for you it’s enough if a criminal “cured” from his desire to do crime, no punishment needed? And as I said for myself: certainly not /just/ punishment, but also…
Actually yes, I do feel this way. You stated it exactly.
If we had a psycho pass system that could, with 100% certainty, confirm that a criminal will never commit any crimes again (ethical crimes, not necessarily legal crimes), I would say yes. The problem is that such a system doesn’t exist and it’s highly likely that criminals will be repeat offenders, so we have to “guess” that they are rehabilitated after the punishment.
I don’t think revenge punishment should exist in a just society, only harm minimisation. The punishment needs to be either a deterrent, rehabilitation tool, or harm containment tool, not revenge.
if someone kills one I love, I fear I’d have the need to see them suffer. Surely, I’d personally punish harder in this case, but the law should find a balance here.
Anyway, as you say: we don’t have that system, so we are just discussing the reasons for jail time, not the the if.
Wouldn’t a 93 year old have been like 9 years old in 1942? I’m aware of the Nazi Youth, but I’m pretty sure it was mandatory.
Not saying I know for sure that the guy didn’t do evil shit, he very well might have. But I dunno, he was a literal child.
Anyone who said that shit about the Golden State Killer is a fucking moron though.
https://www.npr.org/2021/10/07/1043971890/100-year-old-nazi-guard-on-trial-germany
He was 100, and it was 2021, but damn I hate how easily you came up with excuses on vague time frames.
I wasn’t trying to come up with excuses, I literally just did some basic math to try to figure out how old the guy was during the war.
Sorry that I don’t think a 9yr old is necessarily a fully formed fucking Nazi
Why’d you do the math?
Because WW2 was 80+ goddamn years ago so I was curious how old the person would have been at the time?
It’s also just kind of how my brain works.
We’re not talking doing calculus here, it was one addition/subtraction operation. That’s it. We’re not doing rocket science here.
I said Nazi. Definite Nazi. Like 93. Not that long ago. You took that and said “he was a literal child.” Even you said the Hitler Youth was mandatory. So either the entire population of Germany should’ve been jailed, if that were jailable, or he did something worse. So you could’ve asked for more information or done research, but you invented a scenario where the Nazi might not have been so bad.
Fuck that. This is exactly what I was talking about.
“Fuck you for pointing out that I’m wrong” okay buddy. If you had used facts instead of guesses we wouldn’t even be going down this thread
You don’t know how quotes work, or you’re replying to the wrong person.
fuck you mean “why’d you do the math” ?
You didn’t think the German Court that convicted him had done the math first? Or heard the evidence?
yeah, i guess i haven’t thought about that.
What would the math get you except for a reason a Nazi might not be so bad?
I did the math without thinking of any greater implications because I was curious and because I’m always doing math in my head. I don’t need any grand reasons to do simple math. What the math gave me was an answer to the question “how old would a 93 year old be in 1945?” Also, I would hope that if someone told you a 9 year old was a war criminal you wouldn’t just accept it on face value.
You gave shitty information and are accusing the person who called you on it of trying to find excuses for Nazis. That’s completely ridiculous.
Nazi was the only definite information I gave. They could’ve asked for more info or tried to look it up, but instead we came to “he was a literal child.” Don’t invent a life story for a Nazi that lets them off the hook.
over-pessimism?
What?