• 2 Posts
  • 163 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 4th, 2023

help-circle















  • It would be exceedingly rare for one party to get enough votes to form a majority under PR.

    The current system would encourage the formation of coalition governments. Those coalitions would probably not look too different from the big parties we currently have since parties would only group together if they have sufficiently similar goals. This does make it very likely that the majority coalition maintains a fairly stable high level agenda over time.

    Barring a trump-style lunatic jacking up the executive branch

    It could happen, but that’s not what I’m worried about. I don’t believe that any single law we pass would be deemed unjust in isolation, but the totality of laws can be. If everything is set up to benefit the majority, then everyone else gets left behind. It’s not a matter of malice. They’re just not considered in the calculus.

    An example that comes to mind is the treatment of native Americans. They keep getting the short end of the stick, and while some concessions are made, it’s never because someone looked at the numbers and decided their situation was unfair. It happens because of some combination of public pressure and the benevolence of the people in charge. How many other such groups are there that are still getting completely ignored because the public don’t know about them?



  • I don’t see how the vote count contradicts that message. As of this moment, the vote count (upvotes - downvotes) is 110 on the parent comment criticizing the use of AI art and 260 on the main post. Technically a minority, but it’s a sizable minority.

    I also don’t agree that it’s off-topic. The contents of the meme is the topic. The contents are AI generated, so that makes it one of the topics.