• 0 Posts
  • 21 Comments
Joined 28 days ago
cake
Cake day: October 25th, 2026

help-circle












  • Well there’s evidence the siege of Troy actually happened in the bronze age. Homers illiad and odyssey are also definitely refering to the bronze age era.

    My point being - It should been at least interesting. I found it boring to see the same greek armor being used for everything, when we know they were a diverse bunch, let alone for something that supposedly took place thousands of years before. You wouldn’t have complained if Nolan used era authentic armor, but it would have added to the charm.

    Homeric descriptions of combat were, and I’m saying this as someone that’s trained in fighting of various sorts, laughable.

    Yeah, it’s a myth. To be honest it fails in my eyes there as well. It’s not a very epic myth, everything feels so small. I wanted to see a grand Troy being seiged by hundreds of thousands of people. I get that it’s trying to be more grounded, but I thought it wasn’t supposed to be realistic.

    If you are going to represent an epic, why not go all the way? Why is it grounded in only some places but doesnt care to be grounded in history?





  • It simply isn’t about realism.

    Sure movies don’t have to be realistic, but they have to be entertaining.

    Having era authentic production can be a part of what appeals to people.

    The immersion break of “dad” is more about the audience’s expectations of any far past setting using theatrical formality than any unrealistic placement.

    He’s not complaining about that. The movie has straight up some atrocious on the face dialogue. It has little subtext and leaves little for the mind to imagine. Good dialogue is the opposite. People like to infer what the character is saying over what they actually mean.

    And from what I can tell, if it was trying to emulate the illiad’s style of prose, it fails at it.

    Nolan has some really good movies, but I’d get his brother or another writer to edit his writing for the big screen.