• 246 Posts
  • 197 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: December 18th, 2021

help-circle






















  • By “independent”, that means free from undue influence from other branches of government

    Security clearances can play an important role in our electoral system, but must be carefully designed. If failing a clearance disqualifies candidates, then several critical safeguards must be in place.

    The clearance process must be:

    • Administered by a truly independent, non-partisan body with clear oversight
    • Completely transparent in its methodology and criteria
    • Applied equally to all candidates regardless of party affiliation
    • Subject to meaningful appeal mechanisms through our courts
    • Protected against partisan manipulation
    • Focused only on legitimate security concerns (foreign influence, corruption)

    Having the intelligence arm of the government administer clearances without independent oversight creates dangerous potential for abuse. Intelligence agencies should provide information, but final determinations should be made by a body insulated from political pressure from the executive or legislative branches.

    As for your second question about electoral reform - the math is clear. Neither the Liberals nor Conservatives have demonstrated genuine interest in proportional representation. The Liberals have repeatedly promised reform (since 1919!) only to abandon it once in power. Trudeau’s explicit admission that they were “deliberately vague” to appeal to electoral reform advocates speaks volumes.

    The only parties consistently supporting proportional representation are the Green🟢/NDP🟧/Bloc⚜️. None may form a majority government under our current system precisely because FPTP systematically disadvantages smaller parties.

    That’s the catch-22 of electoral reform: the parties that benefit from the broken system have no incentive to fix it. This is why focusing on principled candidates who support PR, regardless of their chance of forming government, is so important.

    Remember, in a democracy, citizens are deserving of and entitled to representation in government. Only PR can dependably deliver that.