I imagine it means they will not allow Canadians to sign up or use the service, because otherwise they’re opening themselves up to legal action by the Canadian government. Signal requires a phone number so they will easily be able to recognize and deny Canadian phone numbers. Internationally though I don’t understand how the Canadian government could enforce it on foreign companies headquartered abroad and storing the data outside of Canada.
Does the canadian govt have the power to punish a company that has no presence in canada for simply allowing canadians to sign up for their service?
If they have no canadian office and no canadian servers, how can they be breaking the law just by allowing canadians to use/sign up for their totally LEGAL services?
Didn’t the UK try and sue 4chan at some point, who responded, quite rightly, “yeah no get fucked lol”, and the UK has only just given up on it after a few years?
In short, I don’t think its any of their fucking business what companies located outside of their own country can and cannot do.
The main issue is with the sweeping global trend towards this authoritarianism, it will become harder and harder to find a country with data centres that doesn’t have the same rules in place.
Signal is actively used by US government officials, though. (Although that might not be enough incentive to pressure canada away from their legislation)
Right, I’ve never gotten that. I guess Canada could maybe block them entirely at the ISP level if they want, I don’t see any reason they wouldn’t respond to insistence they pay a fine with a simple “lol no”. It’s not Signal’s obligation as a foreign entity to enforce local laws. If Canadians aren’t supposed to use Signal, it’s Canada’s obligation to stop them from using a foreign service, not the foreign service.
I imagine it means they will not allow Canadians to sign up or use the service, because otherwise they’re opening themselves up to legal action by the Canadian government. Signal requires a phone number so they will easily be able to recognize and deny Canadian phone numbers. Internationally though I don’t understand how the Canadian government could enforce it on foreign companies headquartered abroad and storing the data outside of Canada.
I am not a lawyer.
Does the canadian govt have the power to punish a company that has no presence in canada for simply allowing canadians to sign up for their service?
If they have no canadian office and no canadian servers, how can they be breaking the law just by allowing canadians to use/sign up for their totally LEGAL services?
Didn’t the UK try and sue 4chan at some point, who responded, quite rightly, “yeah no get fucked lol”, and the UK has only just given up on it after a few years? In short, I don’t think its any of their fucking business what companies located outside of their own country can and cannot do.
The main issue is with the sweeping global trend towards this authoritarianism, it will become harder and harder to find a country with data centres that doesn’t have the same rules in place.
4chan and the US have some benefits that signal probably wouldn’t have (not giving a shit about Europe, and having large numbers of Tr*mp supporters)
Signal is actively used by US government officials, though. (Although that might not be enough incentive to pressure canada away from their legislation)
Right, I’ve never gotten that. I guess Canada could maybe block them entirely at the ISP level if they want, I don’t see any reason they wouldn’t respond to insistence they pay a fine with a simple “lol no”. It’s not Signal’s obligation as a foreign entity to enforce local laws. If Canadians aren’t supposed to use Signal, it’s Canada’s obligation to stop them from using a foreign service, not the foreign service.